Saturday, January 27, 2018

Crime in Jamaica - By: Sydney Ying

The crime rate in Jamaica has always been on the higher side, but in the past 20-30 years it has gotten much worse, and it is now at a point where it could be considered dangerous to visit the country. Gangs, the government, the police, and some of the locals are all a part of why Jamaica is such a crime-filled country. The port and Falmouth aren’t the issue, it’s the other parts of Jamaica that have the gangs who are associating with political parties that then impact the entirety of Jamaica.  
This is a graph of the murder rate in Jamaica from 1970-2000
In the first 6 days of 2018, Jamaica experienced: 38 murders, 16 shootings, and 17 robberies. “Jamaica's Prime Minister Andrew Holness announced a state of emergency for St. James Parish on Thursday (1/18) and deployed the military to the area amid a rise in violent crime.” (CNN, 1) Because these were based off of issues within the country, tourists were never caught in the crossfire. Unfortunately, over the last year, these shootings have been getting closer to more populated tourist areas. Gangs are the far majority of the people causing shootings in Jamaica, which is  affecting the amount of tourists that come to visit. This is a big problem for Jamaica because tourism is how a big portion of Jamaicans gain income.
The gangs and politicians being associated with each other began long before 1962, (when Jamaica gained its independence from Britain). “Organized crime in Jamaica is full of perils, from gangs that have the muscle to stand up to the state, to gang-leaders who have helped put members of the political elite in office.” (csmoniter, 1) The two political parties (Jamaica Labour Party/JLP and People’s National Party/PNP) would stone, beat, and stab each other in order to gain control of the island. They created rival gangs to fight the opposing supporters, which slowly evolved into “organized criminal networks.” (Canadian Business, 1) Ever since then, it has been apparent that the gangs and who gets elected into the Parliament are correlated.
The National Strategic Anti-Gang Unit has been a big part of getting rid of the gangs. In 2016, they were able to give the police a list of 258 gangs across Jamaica, and arrest 356 gang members. One of the gangs was called One Order which was based in Spanish Town, and they had 3 of their members arrested, each sentenced to at least 5 years in prison. The Jamaican Posse is one of the largest gangs in Jamaica with 13-20 thousand members, and they have a strong affiliation with both the PNP and JLP because of their size and power.
Over the years gang violence has become institutionalized, which in turn has raised the murder rate immensely. Although they were “part of” the government from the beginning, violence between each other as well as pedestrians is what has made the murder rate go up so much. “What’s even more frightening is that the gangs apparently enjoy protection from the authorities because of their political influence.” (J.com, 1) There is crime that happens for revenge or political purposes, but there is also the crime against the things a lot of people in Jamaica, unfortunately, don’t believe in and don’t support; the LGBTQ community for example.
Being part of the LGBTQ community in Jamaica is extremely dangerous, for many reasons. TIME Magazine titled Jamaica “most homophobic country” and although being gay isn’t technically illegal, it is much more than frowned upon. Buggery (anal sex) is seen as a crime, and so is “acts of gross indecency” between men. People who are part of the LGBTQ community are kicked out of their homes, beat by police, publicly shamed, and shunned. Almost every time, none of these things are investigated and no arrests are made. It could be considered that part of the crime is that the police support these acts. The far majority of Jamaicans do not support being gay and would prefer it be illegal. However, these things don’t happen all across Jamaica even though it can seem that way. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XaHSKJReCXE: This video is about the life of the people in LGBTQ community in Jamaica.
Crime occurs mainly in Kingston, Spanish Town, and Montego Bay which is in St. James Parish. Falmouth doesn’t have any significant crime. We stayed in Falmouth, where the port is. Falmouth is definitely the safest of those 3 cities. The security in Falmouth is more than in Montego Bay and Kingston because of the port and tourists within the city. Many of the people we interviewed had mentioned that the security due to the port is a big reason as to why Falmouth is much safer than any other place in Jamaica.
We were fortunate enough not to experience or witness any criminal acts during our stay in Jamaica. However, some of our interviews contained a lot of information on the crime in Montego Bay and Kingston, because it does affect all of Jamaica. Jamaicans rely so much on their tourists, that’s how most of them gain income. However, if the crime doesn’t slow down or nothing improves, it will continue to be an extremely dangerous place and foreigners will be warned to not visit.
This creates multiple problems: There could be more people living in poverty, more unemployed people than there has ever been in Jamaica, more people with weak family structures, and so many more lives could be in danger. The culture is so rich, and there is so much to learn about the history of this country. People do want to learn about it, but if their safety could potentially be in danger, they will not choose to go. As for a solution, I personally would’ve said to have the government pass some new laws or start an organization that can do that with the help of the police. However, if the government and their security is part of what is putting people in danger, who is going to solve this?


Work Cited

Smith-Spark, Laura. “Tourists warned after shootings in Jamaica's Montego Bay.” CNN,

“Jamaica attacks: a legacy of ties between politicians and gangs.” The Christian Science

“Jamaica's Mixture of Gangs and Politics Causes Grave Problem with U.S.”

“38 murders in first six days of 2018.” Lead Stories | Jamaica Gleaner, 8 Jan. 2018,
jamaica-gleaner.com/article/lead-stories/20180108/38-murders-first-six-days-2018.

Porter, Tom. “Tourists have been warned to stay in their resorts in Jamaica as soldiers

Limited, Jamaica Observer. “Gangs still responsible for most murders in 2016.”

Boa, Larry. “Top 10: Notorious Gangs.” AskMen, www.askmen.com/top_10/entertainment/top-10-notorious-gangs_9.html.

Tuesday, January 23, 2018

Politics of the Port

Zoey Weinstein
Dr. Lee and Dr. Q
Falmouth Field School 2018
22 January 2018
Politics of the Port
The Historic Falmouth Cruise Port was built in 2011. It is completely separated from the town of Falmouth, by a huge gate and the port itself is made from artificial landfill. When you enter and exit the port, it's almost like you've left the city because the port is so much more commercialized than the city itself, with many American chain restaurants and chain souvenir shops. The goal of the port bringing more cruise ships to the island, which ultimately means more tourists, which means more money. The port is Located in Falmouth, between two other popular ports, Ocho Rios and Montego Bay. The port is in a perfect location that can accommodate gigantic cruise ships, but is also right outside of Falmouth Historic District. There are so many places to buy T-shirts, jewelry and other souvenirs. This seems like a flawless system for tourists to visit and enjoy Falmouth, but does the port live up to what it was promised to be?
Royal Caribbean cruises and Jamaica’s Port Royal Authority originally said that the port was a place for tourists to have "a wraparound experience not unlike Colonial Williamsburg, but one that is infused with the signature warmth of the Jamaican people." The locals were told that the tourists coming off of the ships would spend at least $100 on the island, but since the ships have been arriving, the locals have been extremely disappointed because the numbers they were receiving were drastically less than what they were told. (Cleveland.com)
According to various trade groups, the cruise ship industry puts $2 billion (USD) per year into the economies of the Caribbean. The catch is that produces relatively little income for the locals because a majority of the tourists spend their money on the overpriced amenities on the ship or on the chain stores and souvenir shops on the port, not in the town itself. (Cleveland.com)
Due to the previous information being from 2012, one would assume a solution would have been found for these issues, but here we are in 2018, and according to Cayman News Service Jamaica Gleaner, and Royal Caribbean Cruise Lines (RCCL) “have decided to take their businesses elsewhere for the coming season and next year,” in order to avoid Falmouth, regardless of the fact that RCCL took a major role in building the port. However, Jamaica’s Port Authority has stated that The Allure of the Seas will return to Falmouth towards the end of 2018. The mayor  of Falmouth, Colin Gager stated that  “the pullout of the three vessels, which together bring in about 10,000 visitors per call to the port, will result in losses of about $5 million (Jamaican dollars) monthly,” which is a huge decline that Falmouth cannot afford to experience in its current economic state. Gager says that  “the cruise lines are concerned about visitor harassment, among other issues.” He  does admit “that visitor harassment has been an  ongoing problem, with the conduct of tour bus operators and craft vendors leaving much to be desired.”
There  have been  other theories on why the ships have been pulled from visiting Falmouth, including Jim Walker’s Cruise Law News, who suggests that based on recent protests in Jamaica regarding the plans that want to continue to dredge the harbor to eventually be able to fit two ships, ultimately destroying the environment there. So is this the reason Royal Caribbean is  pulling their ships,to revolt against the damaging plans? This issue is very controversial and extremely concerning for the people of Falmouth because tourism counts for 15% of the island’s GDP (JIS)
When we went into Falmouth to get interviews for the oral history project, we got many different opinions on  how people felt about the port. A lot of the people we interviewed said that they really liked the port and they thought it brought a lot of tourists to a place in Jamaica where people didn't always visit because people always visited Kingston, Negril and Montego Bay. Many people also said that it brought good business to the stores, restaurants and vendors in Falmouth. Other people we interviewed said that the port did not turn out the way that the locals were told it would be. One person said that the cruise ship said not to leave the port because they would be leaving “at their own risk.” One of  the most popular negative opinions we got was that the Jamaicans obeyed the advice from the cruise ship, stayed in the port, so they ended up eating at chain restaurants and shopping at chain souvenir shops, so the locals aren't making the money they need to sustain a living.


Works Cited
Cruise CriticStaff. “Home.” Terminal: Information for Port of Falmouth - Cruise Critic,

Staff, Associated Press business. “Caribbean Cruises Leave Wave of Bitter Merchants.”

Cayman News. “Three Cruise Ships Switch from Falmouth, Jamaica.” CNS Business, 10 July 2017,

“The World Factbook.” Central Intelligence Agency, Central Intelligence Agency,


By Arjhong Mardani: Social Impact of Tourism in Jamaica


Social Impact of Tourism in Jamaica

    Tourism plays a tremendous role in the lives of Jamaicans, for many it’s their only source of income. As tourism continues to grow in Jamaica, the number of tourists annually surpasses the total population of Jamaica itself. With 3.5 million tourists annually, 1.5 million tourists on commercial cruise ships, and two million stopover visitors, how has Jamaica been impacted socially? More specifically, how has tourism directly affected the well being of Jamaicans?
     Jamaica's tourism started in the mid-twentieth century. It first commenced once invalids began coming to Jamaica in order escape the cold winters in England and North America. Port Antonio and Montego Bay were the first to construct hotels for the tourists. During this period tourism was limited to only a few, this being the rich. After World War I, tourism in Jamaica began to prosper. This was due to the fact that methods of transportation were improved, making it significantly easier to get from one country to another. Dating from 1955 to modern day, the graph below demonstrates the total number of stopovers as well as cruise arrivals, number of visitors and total expenditure.

Year
Total Stopover Arrivals
Total Cruise Arrivals
Total Visitor Arrivals
Total Visitor Expenditure
1955
86,793
35,356**
122,149
£6,718,190
1963
131,865
70,464**
202,329
£13,500,000*
1975
395,809
150,433
553,258
US$128,706,000
1984
603,436
231,039
843,774
US$406,600,000
1994
976,635
595,036
1,108,871
US$919,000,000
2003
1,350,285
1,132,596
2,482,881
US$1,351,142,000
2009
1,831,097
922,349
2,753,446
US$1,925,423,000
2011
1,951,752
1,125,481
3,077,233
US$2,008,343,000
2014
2,080,181
1,423,797
3,503,978
US$2,247,834,000
2015
2,123,042
1,568,702
3,691,744
US$2,402,340,000
2016
2,181,684
1,655,559
3,837,243
US$2,608,798,000

    In the Jamaican community, approximately 200,000 people are employed in correlation with tourism, which contributes to 15% of their countries GDP. This being direct employment, for example, different variations of transportation, craft markets, hotels, as well as indirectly, for example, banks, manufacturing, trading of goods and supplies.  
    As tourism continues to increase, so do new opportunities for Jamaicans. An increase in tourism has lead to an increase in demand. This has encouraged Jamaica to make recent developments in their exports, this being plants, fruits, as well as arts and crafts. Again, with the attraction of tourists, infrastructure plays a major role, these being public facilities, hotels and resorts, and public institutions. Jobs are created and commerce is growing, expensive hotels are profiting as well as local restaurants and farmers.
     Another thing to consider, is tourism sustainable for Jamaica? With the construction of airports, destruction of forests for hotels and attractions, as well as oil refineries being constructed close to wildlife, sustainability seems unprecedented. Many organizations such as the Sandals Foundation and the Rockhouse Foundation strive to make the tourist industry responsible, sustainable, and of benefit for the local communities. Unfortunately, most of the time these organizations are left in a brawl with the government.
    Tourists have also been involved with Jamaica’s rising crime rates in recent days. Jamaica’s crime has kept itself secluded from tourists for the most part, until recent days. This issue has forced Jamaica into a state of emergency. “In 2017 there were 335 murders recorded, just in St. James itself, which includes the popular tourist destination of Montego Bay, reports the Jamaican Observer.”(Cummings) This is an unfortunate social issue, that is being dealt with proper precautions. Due to the fact that crime has spread outside of the locals within Jamaica, it is obtaining major attention, giving Jamaica an atrocious look to outsiders.
    Another question that is presented, is tourism more positively or negatively impacting Jamaica socially? In modern day, tourism is undoubtedly benefiting a large amount of the Jamaican community, helping the economy by creating jobs, inducing the construction of new buildings, creating new developments. As for the long-term perspective, the answer would be negative, simply due to the fact that tourism is not fully sustainable for Jamaicans and unfortunately won't survive if continuing on the same path.
    The social impact of tourism is vast as it affects all of Jamaica. From creating thousands of jobs to the dismantling of the Rainforests, tourism has caused its fair share of ups and downs. As it currently allows Jamaica to prosper and has been in the past, it is unsustainable and often unresponsible.

Work Cited:

Mark Cummings. Limited, Jamaica Observer. “Five shot, 1 dead in St James.” Jamaica     
Observer, 2018,

Not Specified . “The Impact of Tourism on Jamaica Essay.” The Impact of Tourism on Jamaica
Essay - 821 Words | Bartleby, Bartleby.com, 2017, www.bartleby.com/essay/The-Impact-of-Tourism-on-Jamaica-P3JXQCWYTC.

Caribbean360. “Annual tourist arrivals to Jamaica surpass population size.” Caribbean360,

Not Specified . “Tourists in Jamaica warned to stay in resorts after shootings lead to state of

Tips.” Jamaica Tourist Board, Jamaica Tourist Board, 2016,

“What impact has tourism had on the people and the environment of Jamaica? - GCSE
Geography - Marked by Teachers.Com.” Marked by Teachers, The Student Room Group Ltd, 2016, www.markedbyteachers.com/gcse/geography/what-impact-has-tourism-had-on-the-people-and-the-environment-of-jamaica.html.

“How Important Is Tourism To Jamaica?” Thecaribbeancurrent.com, The Caribbean Current , 6